|
Links
The Big Dogs:
InstaPundit James Lileks USS Clueless Eject! Eject! Eject! ![]() More Good Stuff: Amish Tech Support Andrea Harris Asymmetrical Information DailyPundit Dr. Weevil Happy Fun Pundit IMAO Ipse Dixit Ken Layne Kevin Whited (also here) The Laughing Wolf Little Green Footballs Matt Welch Occam's Toothbrush PhotoDude Samizdata.net ScrappleFace Sgt Stryker's Daily Briefing Silflay Hraka a small victory Thinking Meat The Truth Laid Bear Virginia Postrel VodkaPundit The Volokh Conspiracy Winds of Change Random entries from my Blogroll
Powered by Google
Archives
|
January 29, 2003
The Obligatory Two Towers Post
Lileks writes about seeing The Two Towers. I don't have a whole lot to add to what just about everyone else has said on this, but what I have to say involves a spoiler. Click the "More" link only if you've already seen it. One thing that added a certain satisfying zing to the movie was that Viggo Mortenson -- a less-than-thoughtful antiwar activist in real life -- found himself connected to, responding to, and even saying all of these apparently pro-war sentiments: Aragorn's "War is upon you whether you wish it or not"; Eowyn's "We learned long ago that those who have no sword may still die upon one"; Sam's "There is some good in the world, and it's worth fighting for" speech. And more deliciously still, the only spokesman for the anti-war crowd was Grima Wormtongue, with his accusation of "war-mongering" against Eomer. Mortenson must have signed up for the movie well before the 9/11 attacks, and had no idea he would be performing the role of a wartime ruler while a real-life war (commencing, in painfully ironic fashion, with the destruction of two towers) was being waged in the real world. By a Republican President, no less. It's especially interesting given one significant departure from the original work: in the books, the Ents decided at their congress to go to war against Saruman. In the movie, though, they came to the opposite conclusion; but Pippin roused them to fight by showing them that war would inevitably come to them. It makes clear that the "you must fight for what you believe in" message was not just Tolkien's; it was Peter Jackson's as well. The other thing I liked -- and that no one else seems to have noticed or commented upon -- was that the Rohan plotline finished with what must be the oldest cliche in movies: the cavalry riding over the hill to the rescue. Led by a lone rider on a white horse with the speed of light, no less. Heigh-ho, Shadowfax! Awaaaayy! Posted by Kevin Shaum at January 29, 2003 02:26 AMComments
I noticed that. I also noticed (something I haven't seen a comment on either) the scene that was straight out of every a-girl-and-her-horse movie: the one where Gandalf whistles and Shadowfax comes running up. I think no one remarks on that because all thoughts of that equine moment are wiped out by the (semi-computer-enhanced_ shot of Legolas throwing himself up on his horse backwards. I've read a lot of commentary on that. Posted by: Andrea Harris on February 5, 2003 03:12 PMActually it was MERRY who was the rabble rouser amongst the Ents IN THE MOVIE...but that will just seque into one of my tired old rants (amongst my friends anyway) of how off course Jackson/Boyens/Boyd/Monaghan have taken the characters of Merry and Pippin. You don't want me to do that right now... Suffice it to say, rock on! The worst thing you can say about an actor is that they are unbelievable in their role. Trust me. Viggo aint believable to me...which is a pity, cause he had me sold on the character of Aragorn before he decided to shoot his mouth off about real life. Posted by: Sharon Ferguson on February 6, 2003 02:36 PMPost a comment
|
